Paul writes:
Why are there so many negative comments on BEE-L about thymol, apiguard etc,

Paul,
I started this thread in a sincere attempt to find out what the current
status is on the testing of thymol products. I was under the impression that
thymol was not effective and therefore was surprised that there was a
movement underway to get it approved in the US. If it works I will be more
than happy to use it. I do not wish to use coumaphos or any other
insecticides in my hives.

However, if it doesn't work I think people should be clear about this. Or if
it works sometimes, under certain conditions -- conditions which may not
prevail in your area. What if it only works under mediterranean type
conditions? Also, it should be made clear that anything that kills mites has
a high likelihood of harming bees and contaminating honey. Thymol is known to
be absorbed into the honey and combs and give off a very rank odor.

Like I said, I did not start this discussion in order to trash thymol or
promote any point of view, but to get some more information. I have searched
high and low and so far have not found reports of large scale trials. There
appear to be very glowing claims associated with thymol products, mostly made
by people who sell it. I am looking for unbiased evidence that it does or
does not work, that's all.

pb

::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
BEE-L subscribers are reminded to read and follow the
guidelines for posting, which are available online at:
http://www.honeybeeworld.com/bee-l/guidelines.htm
::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::