Subject: | |
From: | |
Reply To: | |
Date: | Sun, 10 Mar 1996 18:16:33 EST |
Content-Type: | text/plain |
Parts/Attachments: |
|
|
---------- Forwarded Message ----------
From: Duncan Broadfoot, 101330,1063
TO: gisele, 101550.2545
DATE: 10/03/96 09:46
RE: Copy of: vit k
Gisele: In the UK vit K was given without consultation until perhaps 4 or 5
years ago. A study was then published suggesting a possible link between
intra-muscular vit k and childhood cancer. This got the whole subject aired,
but has led to some strange practices. Since oral vit k was not implicated,
some breastfed babies are now given the intra-muscular preparation orally, and
mothers are sent home with more to be given after a few weeks. I have never
heard of it being given weekly - I think perhaps 3 doses maximum. If given
intra-muscularly, one dose only immediately after birth. Mothers would be
advised to go for the injection if eg forceps , prem baby, baby bruised. The
regime followed will depend on the mother's choice, and certainly varies
enormously from hospital to hospital. I have heard of mothers being bullied
over this one.
I don't think there is any concern re bottle fed babies - there is lots of vit k
in abm.
Although the cancer study has been largely repudiated by other studies from
Scandinavia, the concern and increased awareness in mothers remain. Childbirth
organisations are concerned that a product which is unlicensed for oral use is
being administered orally. I understand the carrier is phenol - maybe not what
we would choose to feed our newborns.
My personal view is that perhaps vit k deficiency is largely iatrogenic. Given
the restrictive practices in the past, the 'ritual starvation' of newborns
(sorry - can't remember who I'm quoting!) it would hardly be surprising to find
babies deficient in lots of things in the early days. I don't know whether any
studies have looked at populations where adequate early breastfeeding is
practiced?
Looking forward to hearing protocols from the rest of the world -
Mary Broadfoot, Paisley, Scotland
[log in to unmask]
|
|
|