Andreas wrote:

>I would bee especially interested in your thoughts about the new
>Herreweghe version since I liked Bostridge (who sings the evangelist)
>very much in his lieder recordings.

The new version is really well done (almost perfect), but the performance
of 1985 should still be a little better.  Anyway, this is told to me by a
Bach-freak who's searching for the perfection.

Bob Dubois,
department musicology
University of Leuven, Belgium