>To: Robert Johnson <[log in to unmask]> >From: [log in to unmask] (David S. Rotenstein) >Subject: 106 more than Native Americans > >Add my post to the growing list of folks whose fingers can't quite fully depress the delete key where Johnson is concerned. > >Johnson: Get a life. Yes, archaeology and anthropology are politicized disciplines and yes, there are a lot of problems related to the motives and conduct of people engaging in both fields, but why don't you just shut-up and find another forum for your anger. You have a very narrow vision of what archaeology does -- yes, you appear to have an excellent command of the literature and history of archaeology and anthropology and you are an eloquent, but misguided, writer. But, alas, you are an undereducated, sophomoric blowhard with very little of real substance to offer anyone but your overinflated estimation of your own value to the disciplines and society at large. > >Though I am an archaeologist, I choose to practice historical archaeology. As with its prehistoric focus, there are problems of bias and politics rampant in this subfield. And I have chosen to write of them in the past in productive ways. Without the 106 process, a lot of the past would stay where it is today: in the past. There would be no legally mandated means for preserving the material remains of the past and they would be lost forever to utility, transportation or private development. At least within the existing legal and regulatory framework, there is some mechanism to preserve the past, both Native American, and historical (including voluntary and involuntary immigrants). Native Americans fought hard and long to obtain legal protection under NAGPRA, but other groups do not enjoy the same protection. Your vision and reduction of heritage protection under NAGPRA are limited and very narrow. > >That's my two cents. Again, Johnson, get a life and find some better way to use your mind. You are a prime example of how dangerous a little education and a lot of potential are. When I was younger (not that I'm all that old now), I too had a big mouth and a partially developed mind. Fortunately, I learned to control my mouth (and pen). It paid off, too. When the time comes for you to leave school and get a job, be VERY selective of where you send your CV: those of us who read them have very good memories. > >David S. Rotenstein >