Historical archaeologists have been using metal detectors for years. Why this sudden surprise at their use? The last time I saw a metal detector being used by a non-archaeologist was at the Gettysburg Battlefield right next to the signs saying that it was a crime to do so. After we pointed this out to the park ranger, they were stopped, their detector was taken away, their car searched, and they were taken down to the office. I do not know what happened thereafter, but it wasn't archaeology. They had come all the way from Montana for a little detecting. I wholeheartedly agree that we should not be holier-than-thou and should try to bring these folks into the fold, but I am a little tired of people justifying their activities because they do not know any better, are misunderstood, or aren't really doing any damage. Name a Civil War battlefield that has a tenth of what it had 20 years ago. Tom Wheaton Opinions Expressed Are My Own New South Associates and Other Usual Disclaimers 6150 East Ponce de Leon Ave. Stone Mountain, Georgia 30083 404 498 4155