John Gallant, and Dr. Phage write: >... Then, there is the case of Schubert's Tenth, realized from >piano score by Newbold (on Hyperion). It is not "wahoo, the greatest >thing ever", but nonetheless it is good to have it, especially the >haunting, Mahler-like slow movement. I say, let the unearthers and >realizers have at it! I am also grateful for the Elgar Third. But as a general principle after the unearthers and the realizers have done their worst (or best) a healthy skepticism is appropriate. I have profound doubts about the authenticity of the Ives Universe Symphony - not that any fraud was perpetrated- just lots of wishful thinking and unjustified extrapolation. Bernard Chasan