Rob Barnett's Musicweb review of a new Naxos CD of Chadwick overtures and tone poems prompts a couple of thoughts. My post about Naxos releases mentioned that this CD was available only in the US: its appearance on a UK-based website suggests otherwise. The review says: "The coordinators of this series chose well in avoiding the symphonies which have all been recorded before." I have no recollection of a recording of the first symphony during the CD era, and a check of a couple of online outlets found none. I'd be most interested to know of any. Richard Pennycuick [log in to unmask]