Deryk Barker wrote quoting: >Chailly's 5 is beautifully played and recorded but IMHO it doesn't hold a >candle to Inoue - and I'm sure Tony will weigh in with Shipway. I will. However, as many now know, I will soon be rating Rudolf Barshai's recent recording on Laurel the finest Mahler 5th currently before us. I am now working on a review of this release and it will appear very soon on Classical Music On The Web (UK). I will post the URL when it is up. Tony Duggan, England