Remember, almost any review is just one person's opinion... But I share your opinion, Don. I own the recording and like it a lot... I listen to it as much as any other interpretation... which is my standard. I find that I don't go back to those recordings which are a bit too odd or badly done. This recording is in the spirit of the music to me. I don't agree with this review at all... it is a bit different, fun even. Certainly it is NOT superficial... flippant... empty of substance... and comments like those make me wonder about the reviewer, particularly on this recording. Ray Bayles