LACTNET Archives

Lactation Information and Discussion

LACTNET@COMMUNITY.LSOFT.COM

Options: Use Forum View

Use Monospaced Font
Show Text Part by Default
Show All Mail Headers

Message: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Topic: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Author: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]

Print Reply
Subject:
From:
Anne Eglash <[log in to unmask]>
Reply To:
Lactation Information and Discussion <[log in to unmask]>
Date:
Sat, 23 Feb 2013 07:57:39 -0600
Content-Type:
text/plain
Parts/Attachments:
text/plain (104 lines)
Dear all,
I do understand the conflicts that occur in the hospital with moms whose 
babies are not latching, everyone is stressed, baby is hungry, and mom 
needs a feeding plan at discharge. I work in the outpatient setting and 
I also do hospital work and see newborns at the hospital, so this is 
something I deal with too.
First of all I know that nurses are using nipple shields even in the 
first 24 hours, not only in my institution, but from what I have heard 
from several of you who have written privately to me. I think that is 
ridiculous and there is no 'excuse' for using a shield at that time. As 
far as I am concerned, using a shield in the first 24 hours is 
unethical, because the risk of the shield is being taken (possible 
change in hormone physiology, changing infant 'target') before the baby 
has been given fair chance to gather up his neurologic senses to 
effectively latch. To me that makes absolutely no sense.
So what about at a 48-72 hour discharge? Some of you have written to me 
about cases where there seemed to be no choice, ie mom has no access to 
a pump, she is going to throw in the towel, baby is frantic and needs to 
be at the breast to instill confidence, etc. Well, I know that there are 
moms who are leaving with a nipple shield, who do absolutely fine with 
breastfeeding down the road. However, I know, based on my experiences 
that not every health care provider who hands out a shield is giving 
proper education on the theoretic risks of the shield. I say theoretic 
because we have no *good quality* evidence for or against the shield, 
just case reports.
My bottom lines are these:
1. We have no good evidence that using a shield is safe. Someone 
mentioned the Chertok study. But like all other nipple shield studies it 
is very small (n=54). It is very poorly done...it states that infant 
growth is no different between nipple shield users and nonusers, but the 
study does not describe how much the mothers were breast vs bottle vs 
formula feeding! Clearly the reviewers didn't know how to assess a 
breastfeeding article, and not surprisingly the article was not 
published in a breastfeeding- knowledgeable journal. Just as I concluded 
in my literature review of nipple shield use in 2010, I still conclude 
that we have no good evidence.
2. Given that we have no good evidence (other than case reports) for the 
*safety* of shields, I feel that families need *informed consent*. IF 
they are given shields at time of hospital discharge, they need to 
understand that the shield*could* impact milk transfer, the shield 
*could* make it harder for the infant to eventually latch on his own, 
the shield *could* cause more sore nipples, and the shield *might* be 
associated with a lowered milk supply. The reason I put in the 'coulds' 
and 'might' is because we have no evidence that the shield does not do 
these things, and based on our knowledge of physiology, the shield could 
certainly do these things. Yes, there are cases where none of these 
things occur, but we cannot make evidence-based clinical decisions on 
case reports. These families need to be followed closely to make sure 
that mom is maintaining her supply and the baby is growing well, and 
that she is taught techniques to discontinue the shield, as well as 
proper care of the shield. I don't expect that hospital nurses have the 
ability to counsel on all of these things, since they typically are not 
following these families longitudinally after discharge.
3. I feel that the nipple shield is the equivalent of breastfeeding 
fast-food. All families should be given the confidence that babies have 
a *deep, very strong instinctual reflex* to latch and nurse. I feel that 
this message is lost, and families are frantic if the baby does not 
latch in the first day or 2. Everyone needs to calm down. It is possible 
that handing over an nipple shield is like throwing a wrench into the 
anxiety rather than calming and reassuring everyone that the baby needs 
time, bonding, and some flow of intuition between mom and baby.  I find 
that I spend a lot of time in my lactation clinic coaching moms that the 
baby can and will latch, and how to drum up that reflex, using STS and 
infant-led latch, not when the baby is really hungry, but when the baby 
is fed, relaxed, but interested in sucking. Yes, that might not happen 
in the first few weeks, but it will eventually, and everyone needs 
patience. But if the baby is always expecting silicone when he wriggles 
down to the breast, it might take longer for that baby to latch without 
the shield. Hospital staff are not managing these moms and babies over 
the next few years like I am, so they don't see the long-term impact of 
handing out these shields.
I could go on and on. Health care providers need to avoid doing harm. 
Above all else, health care providers must give evidence-based informed 
consent so families can 1) make good decisions  and 2) have tools and 
resources to preserve breastfeeding upon being handed a nipple shield.
Anne

Anne Eglash MD, FABM, IBCLC
Clinical Professor
Dept of Family Medicine
Medical Director UW Lactation Clinic
University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health
600 N. 8th St.
Mount Horeb, WI, 53572
608-437-3064 (O)
608-437-4542 (fax)
608-550-3054 (pager)






             ***********************************************

Archives: http://community.lsoft.com/archives/LACTNET.html
To reach list owners: [log in to unmask]
Mail all list management commands to: [log in to unmask]
COMMANDS:
1. To temporarily stop your subscription write in the body of an email: set lactnet nomail
2. To start it again: set lactnet mail
3. To unsubscribe: unsubscribe lactnet
4. To get a comprehensive list of rules and directions: get lactnet welcome

ATOM RSS1 RSS2