Celine Frisch is a young adult artist who is featured on Harmonia Mundi's
Les Nouveaux Interpretes series with a Bach recital of harpsichord works
consisting of the C major Prelude & Fugue from Book 2 of the Well Tempered
Clavier, the French Suite No.  5 in G major, Suite BWV 818a, Toccata BWV
912, and the English Suite No.  3 in G minor.  This is a fine program to
begin Frisch's recording tenure as a featured artist with Harmonia Mundi.
Most reviews I have read are highly complimentary and indicate that Frisch
is a Bach artist well worth watching in the future.  The catalog number is
HMN 911707.

The program begins with the C major Prelude & Fugue BWV 870.  For
comparison, I used Gould's performances on Sony where he couples an
excellent prelude with an absolutely sensational fugue.  After listening
to Frisch's prelude a few times, my enthusiasm waned some.  There's little
subtlety or nuance, and the descending chromatic lines are not very
attractive.  It's an "in your face" reading.  However, her C major Fugue
is superb - fast, thrilling, and the equal of the slower Gould performance.

Next on the program is the French Suite No.5 in G major.  For this
comparison, I used Davitt Moroney's exceptional reading on Virgin
Veritas.  Frisch's opening Allemande has all the delicacy, subtlety,
and beauty I could ask for.  However, the exuberant Courante is more
exciting in Moroney's hands.  The sublime Sarabande is excellently served
by Frisch; she's faster than Moroney but just as wide-ranging and deep in
emotions.  Frisch continues with faster tempos than Moroney in the happy
and joy-filled Gavotte and Bourree.  I prefer her faster speed in the
Gavotte, but the Bourree finds her somewhat hectic.  The Loure is highly
elegant and ornamented music with a halting rhythm.  Frisch is outstanding
here as she takes me to exquisite lands; Moroney has some odd note values
which reduce enjoyment.  Both Moroney and Frisch are very exciting in the
concluding Gigue which just might be the best gigue written by anyone.
This is a very impressive G major Suite from Frisch which stands up well
to the Moroney recording.

Suite BWV 818a in A minor is sometimes coupled with the French Suites as
is the case with the Moroney and Hogwood sets of the French Suites; Robert
Hill also includes BWV 818 on a Hanssler disc of assorted Bach works.  My
favorite is the Hogwood which I used for comparison with Frisch.  Hogwood
is not the slowest of performers, but Frisch is faster in all six
movements.  The Fort gai and Courante do not benefit from Frisch's tempos,
but the Gigue is quite exciting.  The big news is that her Allemande and
Sarabande are the best I've heard.  Overall, I now consider Frisch's the
best recording of BWV 818a.

The Toccata in D major BWV 912 is a good test for Frisch to display
her playful and youthful side.  I'm in the process of reviewing a few
recordings of the seven Toccatas, and I have already finished listening to
the D major versions.  Watchorn is my favorite as he gives himself entirely
to the exuberance of his youth.  Frisch continues with faster tempos than
the alternatives.  Watchorn, at 12 minutes, is not slow at all; Gould takes
over 14 minutes.  By comparison, Frisch is about 10 minutes in length.
However, it never hurts her performance, not even in the Adagio in F sharp
minor Fugue where she still manages to bring out a wide range of emotional
variety and with depth.  As for being young, that's no problem for her at
all as she equals Watchorn.  Frisch's is a wonderful interpretation with
superb execution.

Closing out the program is the English Suite No.  3 in G minor.
Leonhardt's version, even with his routine skipping of repeats, is
excellent and the one I compared to Frisch.  Again, she is faster than
the average in every movement and fully the equal of her competition.  The
depth she displays in the Sarabande at her quick tempo is just amazing.

I predict a great career for Celine Frisch as a Bach performer.  She
has all the technique needed and always gets to the core of Bach's music.
When excitement and thrills are called for, she delivers.  When depth and
introspection are needed, she fully supplies them.  Frisch never is wayward
or putting herself ahead of the music.  In very recent years, new and major
Bach performers such as Edward Parmentier and Richard Troeger are being
recognized.  I think that Celine Frisch has all the tools to surpass them
and become one of the masters of performing Bach.  There's just a little
adjustment she needs to make - every movement of every work doesn't have to
be faster than the norm.  Even though she handles fast tempos excellently,
a little less predictability is in order.  I think that Frisch will
naturally become more discriminating in her choices of tempo as she
matures.  Once that's accomplished, the sky is the limit.

Don's Conclusions:  Celine Frisch's Bach recital disc is a must-buy.  At
a young age, she already meets the challenges of artists such as Leonhardt
and Moroney.  With great playing and an excellent selection of Bach works,
the recording is a winner on all counts except for the C major Prelude from
the WTC.  I'm looking forward to her new disc of the Bach Sonatas for Viol
and Harpsichord where I can hear how well she does as a member of a musical
team.

Don Satz
[log in to unmask]