Henk van Tuijl ([log in to unmask]) wrote:

>Donald Satz wrote:
>
>>I don't have the Duchable/Plasson, but a review in Gramophone was highly
>>negative.  The Gramophone conclusion was that Duchable displayed not one
>>trace of poetry - just a bunch of note banging. ...
>
>The Grammophone has its facts wrong.  There is enough poetry, as is to be
>expected of Duchable.  However, he sometimes has problems with the
>notes.

Sorry Henk, but you just can't say they have their *facts* wrong when you
are talking about whether playing is poetic or not, it's too subjective.
you could say G has its *opinions* wrong, but that sounds like a rather
arrogant way of saying "I disagree".

Deryk Barker
[log in to unmask]