Stephen Heersink wrote concerning Gardiner's Bach Mass:

>Similar problems occur with the passion and resurrection phrases.  It
>sounds like someone doesn't understand the liturgical significance of
>the works their singing or the notes they're playing.

Since I have never delved into litugical matters and intend to keep it that
way, Gardiner and I must be a good match.

For all those list members who have spoken of Gardiner's music in a
depreciating manner, be assured that the "day of retribution" will be upon
you - 8 straight hours of Gardiner/Bach in a soundproof and locked booth.
I'll be situated outside the booth providing you with increasing doses of
electric current whenever a favorite musical passage is played.

Don Satz
[log in to unmask]