Donald Satz:

>I'm not very familiar with the recordings of Elgar's two Symphonies and
>would like some input concerning the version or versions you like best.

The propulsive and thrilling #1 Hurst/BBC Phil version on Naxos (which
won best recording on BBC Radio 3 Building A Library).  Subtle rubato,
stunning playing and excellent engineering which is natural and full.
A very easy first choice.

The stunning #2 by LPO/Slatkin.  I can add more than the review by
Gramophone.  Slatkin layers waves of sound and the timpani is most
impressive (try the 3rd movement).  The organ is included in the 4th
movt.  A very impressive CD.

David Harbin
Nottingham, UK