Subject: | |
From: | |
Date: | Sat, 8 Jan 2000 00:41:44 -0600 |
Content-Type: | text/plain |
Parts/Attachments: |
|
|
Philip Peters wrote:
>Renato Vinicius wrote:
>
>>Is the series of Jeno Jendo - who I never heard - performing of Beethoven's
>>sonatas, really good or just cheap.
>
>Just cheap. He is a totally unimaginative pianist.
You will have to go into more detail than to just dismiss this artist with
a one liner. I find Jando's playing, especially his WTC recordings to be
beautifully played, technically flawless and most interesting.
>>Could someone of you compare with Brendel, Gilels, Arrau, Kempff or
>>Richter. Is there any pianist of these with whom he look like?
>
>He plays like a bookkeeper, just like Backhaus used to do but Jeno is
>a somewhat less sloppy bookkeper than Backhaus was. The guy to look for
>when wanting to buy one whole set is Schnabel.
You have a lousy bookkeeper then. Mine is posessed of a wonderful
contralto voice and is a consumate musician. I stray though. What's
sloppy about bookkeeping anyway. Sloppy bookeepers go to jail. I must
insist that you give us some good reasons, documented by examples and
comparisons as to why this pianist is so awful. I for one disagree, and
I detest one line dismissals of another's life's work. If you must tear
him down, you must back your claims with something more concrete.
Kevin Sutton
|
|
|