Date: |
Wed, 2 Feb 2000 12:38:59 -0500 |
Subject: |
|
From: |
|
Parts/Attachments: |
|
|
Tony Duggan wrote:
>The best advice is to take a look in the List Archive under "Eroica
>Repeats" from a couple of years ago and you will find enough mails on the
>subject to keep you going from Pancake Tuesday to Sheffield Wednesday!
>Many who lived through that discussion (and I was one of them) came to
>refer to it off-list as "The Thread From Hell". On reflection, as much
>light as well as heat WAS thrown on the subject though, at the time, it
>seemed that the opposite was the case. I, and I would not be surprised
>if there are others who agree with me, said all that I ever wanted to say
>on the subject then. It's a fascinating topic but it is surprising just
>how passionate people can get about it.
Yet again, it's one of those which was a subject of so much passion in the
Letters column of Gramophone! At least there nobody complained when the
Editor parenthetically declared the correspondence closed (usually after
a letter from some major figure)--until it started up again a few years
later.
Two personal remarks--taking ALL the repeats [including the Minuet/Scherzo
repeats in the Da Capo] in the late Mozart-Haydn symphonies and the
first two Beethoven gives the work as a whole an entirely different
psychological/dramatic balance than otherwise. This is particularly true
with the Minuet/Scherzo Da Capo- it makes that movement a much better
counterweight to the slow movement. In Beethoven, where the middle period
quartets are so striking in their arrangement of double scherzo/trio
structure [likewise Symphony 5 (originally), 6 and 7] we can now see that
this is a sort of variation on the earlier pattern.
I conducted Haydn 101 on 15 January with every possible repeat. The
wife of one of my colleagues was in the audience in the row behind the
proverbial "woman of a certain age", who, after the Minuetto ended remarked
to her neighbor, "He [JL] didn't seem at all to notice that they kept
playing the same thing over and over again!"
Further comment not required.
Joel Lazar
Bethesda Maryland
|
|
|