Date: |
Thu, 4 Nov 1999 08:48:13 PST |
Subject: |
|
From: |
|
Parts/Attachments: |
|
|
Matt Hoyle is looking for recommendations for the complete cycle of
Beethoven piano sonatas. Matt mentioned Ashkenazy on Philips; I believe
that cycle is on London/Decca. I like Ashkenazy in these works; he has
a nice flow, and forward momentum in the more dramatic movements is
excellent. I've been buying the Russell Sherman volumes on the GM label,
and although I enjoy Sherman in this repertoire, he could take some
pointers from Ashkenazy concerning forward momentum. Sherman has a
tendency to be somewhat mannered when it's time for propulsion - little
hesitations which, imho, retard the natural flow.
My only problem with the Ashkenazy set is what I hear as a tubby sound -
not a big problem since the performances are so good.
Matt also mentioned the Kempff series. That's also very good, loaded
with insights. Some other cycles that come to mind:
Goode on Nonesuch - has received some stellar reviews, but I'm not
convinced. I find Goode very mainstream and ordinary.
Lortie on Chandos - Best to avoid this one. I just don't think that
Beethoven plays into Lortie's strengths.
Kovachevich on EMI - Excellent playing, but the sound tends to be harsh.
Others think differently.
Roberts on Nimbus - Great piano sound with good but not outstanding
interpretations.
Don Satz
[log in to unmask]
|
|
|