Alison Bowcott ([log in to unmask]) wrote:
>Could someone (hopefully Mr D Barker will know the answer to this) please
I'm flattered, but I'm afraid I have no idea. (Scherezade is not one
of "my" pieces and Ormandy is not one of "my" conductors).
>tell me WHY the Ormandy/Philadelphia 1962 version on Sony Classics has
>an extra bar added in the second movement (last 3 bars have become 4!)
Is the bar a repeat of the previous, or new material?
>and a great chunk missing from the 3rd movement? It's a good performance
>otherwise, although I prefer Beecham. I hope someone can answer this for
>me.
It wouldn't be the first time that a work has been cut for recording:
Rachmaninov not only sanctioned cuts to his 3rd piano concerto, I believe
his own recording has them (someone will correct me if I'm wrong).
And old Mr. Faithful-to-the-Text (Toscanini) notoriously large cut in
the finale of Tchaikovsky's Manfred Symphony.
Deryk Barker
[log in to unmask]