Subject: | |
From: | |
Reply To: | |
Date: | Mon, 3 Jan 2000 16:14:53 -0700 |
Content-Type: | text/plain |
Parts/Attachments: |
|
|
Mark Michel wrote (on BEE-L, in part):
>North American persons will be able to view a PBS television program " Tales
>of the Hive", this coming Tuesday.
>Everyone else can enjoy their web site http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/bees/
>I hope the program is as interesting as the web site.
May I insert a bit of reality. As beekeepers and others watch the
program, they might well consider a few relevant facts provided earlier on
this network:
1) In its half century of existence, the bee language hypothesis has
provided no practical benefit to beekeepers;
2) Apparently no one has been able to repeat James Gould's experiments and
obtain his results (a requisite before one should accept such results);
3) Language proponents no longer seem able to phrase a concise scientific
statement (one with predictive power) of their favored hypothesis, a
necessary condition for future quality research;
4) Much evidence has accumulated that sharply conflicts with the original
1946 Karl von Frisch interpretation (Wenner, A.M. and P.H. Wells 1990, Kak,
S.C. 1991, Vadas, R.L. Jr. 1994;
5) A 1937 von Frisch interpretation about odor search behavior has more
validity than the highly touted language notion (Wenner, A.M. with K. von
Frisch 1993).
[ I can readily furnish any of the above mentioned articles,given a mailing
address. ]
Those interested might also read a letter of mine that I believe will
appear in the January issue of the AMERICAN BEE JOURNAL.
**********
When all is considered, perhaps the NOVA program might better be titled,
"Fairy Tales from the Hive."
Adrian
Adrian M. Wenner (805) 963-8508 (home phone)
967 Garcia Road (805) 893-8062 (UCSB FAX)
Santa Barbara, CA 93106
****************************************************************************
*******
*
* "The history of physics is the history of giving up cherished ideas."
*
* Andrew Strominger, Harvard physicist (1999)
*
****************************************************************************
*******
|
|
|