Articulations thar appear to be "contradictory" are not necessarily
confusing of difficult for audiences to absorb. One example: in the
first movement of the Symphony of Psalms the four-note ostinato is played
simultaneously by some instruments in staccato articulation and others
in a more sustained delivery. For some older examples, look to the
ever-popular "Scheherezade." Here, in the second movement, there are
woodwind cadenzas (sustained) over plucked strings (staccato), and in the
fourth movement there is one noteworthy episode where woodwinds deliver a
sustained rendition of the "princess" theme from the third movement over
a virtuosic staccato obbligato from the trumpet (non-double tonguers
beware!).
Aaron J. Rabushka
[log in to unmask]