Subject: | |
From: | |
Reply To: | |
Date: | Sat, 3 Sep 2005 08:46:26 -0400 |
Content-Type: | text/plain |
Parts/Attachments: |
|
|
Eric Brown wrote:
>First, small cell beekeepers are clearly well out of the mainstream (as am
>I), and so there are a lot of management differences that might be the
>cause of whatever successes small cell beekeepers have had. In fact, it
>seems to me that the vast majority of beekeepers who take their bees very
>seriously, don't blindly accept the standard practices, and are willing to
>do costly and labor-intensive things for their bees are quite successful
>beekeepers (in terms of varroa), regardless of whether they use small
>cell. Joe speculated that small cell failures might be beekeeper failures,
>but I would counter that "small cell successes" might be "beekeeper
>successes" having little or nothing to do with cell size.
>
>
I noticed in replies to your posts that a key to success was culling of
the ones that did not make it. That seems to be more the bee than the
cells. That is a standard technique for most of us in the North who
raise their own.
Second is new comb, which is always a good beekeeping practice.
And there is always the "other measures", which seem to crop up in most
discussions.
I have asked knowledgeable beekeepers and still have not seen a
scientific study on small cells that has controls and varroa pressure
over time, especially in the north. I have no problem with the claims of
those who have succeeded with it, but I can claim excellent
overwintering with my techniques and 4.9 cell is not involved. Plus, I
can use standard equipment, no contamination, and keep it simple (and
illegal with OA). I did use 5.0 and it seemed to work for a while.
If I was a commercial operator outside the current AHB areas (of which
FL is one), I would want some good data before I ventured out into a
promising but unproven management technique. Especially if some
knowledgeable and exceptional commercial peers have tried it and found
it wanting.
Bill Truesdell
Bath, Maine
-- Visit www.honeybeeworld.com/bee-l for rules, FAQ and other info ---
|
|
|