Subject: | |
From: | |
Date: | Wed, 29 Oct 2003 12:57:28 +0100 |
Content-Type: | text/plain |
Parts/Attachments: |
|
|
Deryk Barker:
>Does anyone know anything about this?
Charles Mackerras recorded "the Initial Performing Version of the Slow
Movement", I believe this is what you've heard. It is on the Telarc
disc with the first symphony (which is - as the whole cycle not particularly
commendable, due to the utterly poor horn playing).
>I wonder who did the reconstructiuon (and when) and why it was necessary.
While this isn't clear in the Telarc notes, I believe it to have been
made by Robert Pascall. As to why, he writes: "Altogether these changes
provide a deeply fascinating insight into genius at work." To me, this
sounds like the usual "wahoo, we found something by a known composer,
let's call it the greatest thing ever", similar to Beethoven's tenth or
the Bruckner 9 finale. Of course, this "unique" view into a composer at
work is familiar from BIS' busy unearthing of Sibelius sketches.
Jan
|
|
|