Date: |
Wed, 24 Apr 2002 18:13:09 -0700 |
Subject: |
|
From: |
|
Parts/Attachments: |
|
|
Dubiousness of the the study aside, what bothers me about the Mozart
Effect is its researchers' attempt to "medicalize," if you will, the act
of listening to a certain type of music. It shifts people's attention
away from music's inherent value and emphasizes the incidental.
During my first year teaching I received a letter in the mail that set my
teeth on edge--preliminary notice that all music teachers were going to be
laid off. A veteran teacher pulled me aside and explained that it was all
a game: the district wanted to see if parents and teachers would fight to
keep the program, otherwise.... This went on six of the seven years I
taught.
Part of our offensive was handing out flyers during "recruitment" day that
celebrated all the benefits of music education--benefits similar to those
purported by the Mozart researchers--and finally, way down at the bottom of
the list was something like, "music delights with neat sounds." Should it
be about anything more than that?
John Smyth
|
|
|