Jeffrey Hall:

>Szell's set on Sony gets a rosette in the Penguin Guide.

And I forgot to include it in my own pantheon of complete Schumanns.  It
is exemplary in the way that Szell is exemplary: it is lean and clean,
rhythmically alive - and that's to Schumann's advantage IMO.

Scott Morrison,
who loves the Schumanns with a clean, lean and rhythmically alive fervor
of his own