Nice survey by John Proffitt. I am glad to see Kurt Sanderling
mentioned, as his Shostakovich partial cycle with the Berlin Symphony is
extraordinary. I do not expect to hear a better 15th (much better than
his own remake of it with the Cleveland Orchestra on Erato). Sanderling
interprets this work with a great deal of irony and darkness, which is
not immediately evident in most interpretations. His comments on this
symphony are very enlightening. I also feel that he has a great 'Babi
Yar' in him and hope he gets to record it some day. Someone in the
'rec.music.classical.recordings' newsgroup commented on attending a
performance of the 8th with Sanderling and the BPO and called it a
shattering experience. How I envy him.
Regarding Rozhdestvensky's cycle, I have some Japanese JVC issues which
sound much better than the issues that have turned up in the U.S. There is
also a new reissue box of this cycle coming up, but I don't know if they
have remastered it or if they're just "boxing" it.
Ramon Khalona