Date: |
Wed, 7 Jun 2000 14:03:15 -0500 |
Subject: |
|
From: |
|
Parts/Attachments: |
|
|
Stirling Newberry ends a long and very interesting essay on Ben Zander:
>Ozawa has shrunk over the years, becoming a fixture through which poured
>money. Zander has grown. He has aquired the baton technique he lacked, he
>has learned some finesse that he should have aquired from his mentors, he
>has polished his ability to accept just compliments gracefully. Perhaps he
>makes other uneasy because of his abundant messiah complex.
>
>But then perhaps we are in need of someone willing to bear some thorns so
>as to rise to that higher station.
I have been familiar with Zander's work since the mid seventies. For
one year my daughter played viola in the Youth Orchestra and I still
remember a great performance of Haydn's 88 th Symphony. And over the
years I have attended many concerts with the "adult" orchestras he has
conducted- mixtures of students, amateurs, and (for want of a better word)
ringers. Zander's modus operandi is so different from that of a conductor
responsible for an extended and busy schedule that it is not clear (to me)
that he can switch his approach or that he would want to switch. He gives
a relatively small number of concerts a year, and spends large amounts of
rehearsal time on each. Teaching is clearly important to him. I assume
that the conductor of the BSO cannot work that way, but it sure would be an
interesting experiment. I must admit, incidentally, that Zander as prophet
and guru gets on my nerves a bit. He can use a sabbatical from Mahler.
And I also must admit IMHO that Ozawa is better than he was a few years
ago.
Professor Bernard Chasan
Physics Department, Boston University
|
|
|