Kathy I shared your post with my neighbor/friend/mentor. The following
is her response. Please feel free to contact her directly for more
information if you need to at SUSAN LUDWIG
<[log in to unmask]>. Her response is as follows:
> Monique,
>
> Thanks for sharing the case with me.
>
> There were several things that struck me while scanning the posting from
> your list.
>
> The first cause of concern is the terminology that the author uses quoting
> the high school counselor. In my experience, most high school counselors as
> well as many other professionals do not have much, if any, formal education
> relating to parenting or early child development. My red flag is an adult
> making the statement that a parent is "giving in to anything the baby
> wants." This is probably an extreme overgeneralization and shows that the
> person making the statement is harboring judgement and biases towards the
> teen parent.
>
> From my point of view, responding to an infant's needs is a very positive
> thing. Many teen parents are not tuned in enough to even notice when their
> child does have a need. This is not because they don't care or are "bad"
> people but rather because, as expected, most teens are not developmentally
> ready to respond to the needs of another individual due to the egocentric
> nature of their own self-awareness. The issue is clearly that the teen
> parents, both of them, require on-going and intense mental health and social
> support which should include a home visiting program and positive parenting
> education. If this is a client of a public welfare program, then these
> interventions can most definitely be tied to on-going receipt of TANF or
> public welfare funds but bear in mind, the primary goal is adhearance to the
> plan in order to help the family, not to punish them or sanction them for
> failure to be successful. In addition, if these are students enrolled in a
> high school program, the school district, by accepting additional funding to
> provide services for enrolled teen parents, should be providing
> comprehensive parenthood education and counseling. Any support service
> provider, such as a Breast Feeding Consultant, can act as an advocate to
> ensure that the parents are receiving the proper level of services. It just
> takes a release to share information, parent permission, and a phone call to
> the school.
>
> The counselor was correct to contact the local Child Protective Service
> program but should not stop there. Any hitting of any child is serious.
> While I maintain a policy that hitting is never acceptable, many states do
> not consider spanking abuse but rather a "poor" parenting choice that cannot
> be controlled by law. However, combined with other risks, (poor hygiene and
> health care, improper nutrition care, failure to use car seats consistently,
> etc..), the state can open a case which would allow the family a network of
> support to begin, all with the goal is teaching the parents how to best care
> for and bond with their child. Each professional working with this family
> should be contacting the Child Protective Services over and over, to share
> all information that would assist them in determining the best route of
> action. Failure to speak up can only hinder the parents success. I often
> find professionals unwilling to "report" their clients because they feel
> they can help them if they maintain confidentiality, or they are on the
> verge of a success breakthrough. In reality, it takes a network to really
> help change lives, not just one worker. We do an injustice to others when
> we think we can manage their problems on our own. This family needs to be
> given the tools to do without the need for any future workers.
>
> "Holy terror"???? Indeed, children should not be labeled in this way, ever.
> The child's behavior should be described objectively and with the intent to
> help. Is the child acting out by crying and tantruming? This is great. It
> must mean that the child is bonded at some level to the parent. Children
> often act out in front of their own parents. That's where they should do
> this. Hopefully, it's where they feel safe enough to let the whole world
> fall apart for however long it takes to unwind. If I was a 16 month old
> who'd been away from my parent, I think sharing this frustration would be
> top on my list as soon as I saw them. The parents should be given
> information about how to help the child transition back into their care, to
> allow the child to express their feelings, yet provide boundaries about safe
> unleasing of tensions and stresses. If the child just ignored the parent
> and went off blindly with them, hardly responding to them, this would be far
> more cause of concern to me. If, in fact, mom is ready to stop bf, she
> needs to be supported to introduce a new bonding activity with the child
> upon their greeting. (i.e. rocking in a chair for a few minutes while
> drinking ebm from a cup). The transition from bf is dramatic for any child,
> especially those whose parents do not have a full and healthy "tool bag" to
> use to help their child. It's no wonder the child is acting out. I'm sure
> the child senses things are not the same as well as the parent's
> resentfulness. It seems a great time to cease the activity. Teen parents
> do need more time than other parents to be a "teen". They have their own
> needs to be met as well, unlike many older parents. They should not be
> punished that they "cannot" meet needs in the same way other parents can...
> It's not their fault. Yes, they did get pregnant, but no teen can begin to
> rationalize the demands that will be placed on them. They think about
> parenting in a magical, unrealistic fashion, and no amount of criticizing or
> punishing will change that. They need time to develop and mature, as well
> as support and education.
>
> Taking a child away from it's parents is severe. It is not productive for
> the parent or the child unless the child/parent are in serious danger of
> harm. From the limited information, I believe education will be the key for
> this family. The parent who believes that spanking is an acceptable form of
> so called discipline will be exceptionally challenging to intervene with,
> however, it is possible that the parent spanks because they do not have any
> other belief or tool that is better. Someone needs to take some
> responsibility to make a difference in this parent and child's lives. Good
> luck to them. There's lots of great programs to help.
>
> Susan Ludwig
> Director, High School-based Teen Parent/Child Development Program
> Degree background: Child Development and Social/Behavioral Science
>
--
Monique
Noah 6/97, ?? edd 6/18/00
[log in to unmask]
It will be gone before you know it. The fingerprints on the wall appear
higher and higher. Then suddenly they disappear.
Dorothy Evslin
***********************************************
The LACTNET mailing list is powered by L-Soft's renowned
LISTSERV(R) list management software together with L-Soft's LSMTP(TM)
mailer for lightning fast mail delivery. For more information, go to:
http://www.lsoft.com/LISTSERV-powered.html
|