Richard Pennycuick ([log in to unmask]) wrote:

>by Deutsch numbers or keys, both of which are less easy to remember.  The
>music world has quite happily accepted Mahler's 10th in the Cooke
>performing edition, so why not Schubert's "other" symphonies?

Well a) not everybody has and b) there are 4 different editions
(chronologically Wheeler, Cooke, Carpenter, Mazzetti I think) and c) Mahler
had actually composed an unbroken musical line throughout.  Which is
certainly not the case with Schubert's fragments.

Deryk Barker
[log in to unmask]