Symphony No. 3 'Palo Duro Canyon' 23:39
Concerto for Tuba and Orchestra. 23:57
Christopher Olka, Tuba. Seattle Symphony cond. Gerard Schwarz
Naxos 8.449378 (American Classics)
These are both neo-romantic works. Samuel Jones studied with Howard
Hanson and it shows. In the concerto there are a couple of brief moments
reminiscent of Mahler and Jones actually quotes Wagner. The symphony
begins with the kind of rushing notes that Sibelius used so frequently.
However, Jones certainly has his own voice, and both the concerto and
the symphony show his inventiveness.
The 2006 concerto, which comes first on the disc, opens briefly with the
soloist playing the kind of simple figure you might anticipate from his
instrument but it immediately grows into an unexpectedly lyrical melody.
In much of the concerto the tuba plays softly and as part of the ensemble,
though as a prominent voice always. When a high trumpet plays over the
low tuba what is most noticeable is the wide pitch range of a contrapuntal
passage. Other instances of this are a hushed legato passage with the
violins playing softly over a quiet tuba in the second movement and a
high flute or perhaps piccolo over soft low notes in the third.
The scoring is for a substantial ensemble and the orchestra has plenty
to say throughout. There are loud vigorous sections, with some tension,
especially in the first movement, including some clanging percussion.
The commentator, Steven Lowe hears the first movement as fiercer than
I do. There surely are some strong contrasts, to be sure. Jones likes
dynamic contrast as well as extremes of pitch. The middle movement is
both loud and soft. In the finale there are some notable rising and
falling scale passages. An unusual effect in the finale is a wind tunnel
sound, a tribute to James P. Crowder, an aeronautical engineer and an
amateur tuba player, in whose memory the work was commissioned and who
worked with flow visualization of rapidly moving air on solid surfaces,
as the notes relate.
The concerto's pace is more slow than fast: Movement 1 is Andante con
moto, Movement 2 Andante mosso -Adagietto, and the finale begins Largo
before shifting to Allegro molto. The fast passages are notable for
some very agile fluttering playing by Olka, who has a nice tone throughout.
(A personal disclosure: the bass tuba was my own instrument long ago and
I never dreamed that a tuba player would have a songful concerto like
this to play.)
THE SYMPHONY is in a single movement, though with discernable sections.
The symphony begins with a tape of actual blowing wind. The orchestra's
winds and strings swoop also. Some of the music sounds mysterious.
Early on it takes a solemn, even exalted mood, with plenty of brass and
percussion but not just at high volume. There is a bass tread that is
fairly soft. As in the concerto there is a wide dynamic and pitch range;
the bass is often prominent, sometimes with a high trumpet or horn over
it. Jones uses a large orchestra in this work also, sometimes sparingly.
At the end, which is beautiful, very gentle, bell-like - even
liquid-sounding--percussion is heard.
The subtitle of this work relates to its commission by the Amarillo
Symphony. The Palo Duro Canyon is a natural wonder in the flat Texas
panhandle. The 1992 premiere was at an outdoor amphitheater and there
was a public television broadcasr featuring the work, but I did not see
it. Concerning the work, Jones said that he wanted it to have many
layers of sound and meaning, including an expression of the huge length
of time that went into the formation of the canyon. He also was paying
homage to Native Americans for whom the canyon was sacred.
There is some beautiful music here and all this music is well worth
Copyright 2009 by R. James Tobin
The CLASSICAL mailing list is powered by L-Soft's renowned LISTSERV(R)
list management software together with L-Soft's HDMail High Deliverability
Mailer for reliable, lightning fast mail delivery. For more information,
go to: http://www.lsoft.com/LISTSERV-powered.html