Musicophilia: Tales of Music and the Brain
New York & Toronto: Alfred A. Knopf. 2007. 381 pp.
Summary for the Busy Executive: Sacks at less than his best.
I looked forward to this book. A fan of An Anthropologist on Mars,
The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat, Uncle Tungsten, and, of course,
Awakenings, I thought Sacks, a classical-music fan, would approach this
topic as a busman's holiday.
In a sense, he has, by producing his weakest book. This isn't even a
set of case studies, but mostly random observations of various perceptual
abnormalities (bad and good) with musical symptoms. There's almost no
overarching narrative or even point. Perhaps I'm not Sacks's ideal
reader here, since I know little about brain anatomy. The book seemed
to me to list abnormalities, barely fleshed out by attaching them to
sketches of people (many of them explored in far more depth in Sacks's
earlier work), and then pointing to some abnormality in brain response.
In other words, musical perceptions arise from the physiology of the
brain - normal neural operation as well as that compromised by congenital
abnormalities, brain injury, illness, and so on. Well, duh. Although
scientists and clinicians would rightfully be grateful for the information,
it doesn't make the insight any deeper for the general reader by pointing
to, say, the basal ganglia.
The one really interesting notion was how music may alter brain structures
or neural operations in injured or abnormal brains, but Sacks never goes
into this very deeply. Consequently, there's no suspense, nothing to
be revealed or uncovered. It's a litany of facts and limited conjecture.
Perhaps we know too little of the mind for Sacks to go any further, but
this makes for dull reading.
Sacks could have made up for this lack, as he had in his previous books,
by doing what he does best: giving us a fuller sense of the people who
exhibit these symptoms, but for the most part, the subjects here are
ciphers standing in for a class of patients. Two chapters stand in
exception to this general rule: the ones on the former musician and
musicologist and now severe amnesiac Clive Wearing and on the Williams
Syndrome children. Wearing can't remember from one eye-blink to the
next, but when you put a piece of music in front of him, his old skills
come back. Sacks returns to form retailing the anxieties, frustrations,
fears, and rare joys that come to this man, practically instant by
instant. I may be more interested in Williams Syndrome, since I saw
a documentary on it featuring a Williams-Syndrome child -- a darling,
loving little girl. It surprised me to learn that such sufferers (if
that's the word) are considered retarded, since that's not the impression
I got from this girl -- extremely verbal and with social skills far
beyond her years, but obviously I have no idea what it's like parenting
her day to day.
Overall, however, I must consider the book a disappointment.
The CLASSICAL mailing list is powered by L-Soft's renowned LISTSERV(R)
list management software together with L-Soft's HDMail High Deliverability
Mailer for reliable, lightning fast mail delivery. For more information,
go to: http://www.lsoft.com/LISTSERV-powered.html