CLASSICAL Archives

Moderated Classical Music List

CLASSICAL@COMMUNITY.LSOFT.COM

Options: Use Forum View

Use Monospaced Font
Show Text Part by Default
Show All Mail Headers

Message: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Topic: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]
Author: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]

Print Reply
Subject:
From:
Steve Schwartz <[log in to unmask]>
Reply To:
Moderated Classical Music List <[log in to unmask]>
Date:
Wed, 9 Dec 2009 17:14:10 -0800
Content-Type:
text/plain
Parts/Attachments:
text/plain (146 lines)
Benjamin Britten
Billy Budd, op. 50.

Ian Bostridge (Captain Vere);
Nathan Gunn (Billy Budd);
Gidon Saks (Claggart);
Neal Davies (Mr. Redburn);
Matthew Best (Dansker);
Gentlemen of the London symphony Chorus;
London Symphony Orchestra/Daniel Harding.
Virgin Classics 5 19039 2  TT: 165:48.

Summary for the Busy Executive: Ghost ship.

Today, most writers regard Benjamin Britten as a pre-eminent opera
composer, and with good reason.  In an era where a composer may never
see a second performance (or even a first), his stage works, many of
them expensive to put on, get regular productions and, in many cases,
several recordings.  In that regard alone, Britten ranks with Puccini
and Strauss.  Impressive though I find Britten's achievement in the
theater, I tend to think of him as a brilliant all-rounder, like Mozart
-- with stirring examples in almost every genre except, oddly enough,
the classical symphony and the chamber sonata.

In the late Forties, Britten, fired up by an article by E.M. Forster
on Billy Budd, Sailor approached the novelist about a possible collaboration.
Forster, hesitant at first, came on board when he realized that he didn't
have to rhyme.  Britten also brought in his Albert Herring librettist,
Eric Crozier, to handle the parsing into arias and duets, and so on.
Forster and Crozier came up with a script, which Britten reviewed and
then directed changes on.  The Britten-Forster collaboration had its
snags, particularly when Forster, an admitted non-musician, innocently
passed on criticisms of the music, thus upsetting the sensitive composer.
Britten completed the opera in 1950 as a four-acter.  He never collaborated
with Forster again.  In 1960, he condensed the opera from four to two
acts, and the CD (and just about everyone else) presents the later
version.

Almost every one of Britten's operas concern an alienated figure --
estranged from society either by position (Gloriana, Turn of the Screw),
character (Peter Grimes), sexual orientation (Death in Venice), or ethics
(Owen Wingrave).  Often his operas show the social order as oppressive
and cruel (Albert Herring, Rape of Lucretia).  Midsummer Night's Dream
to a large extent constitutes an exception, although the fact that the
opera concentrates on the forest rather than Athens emphasizes the
separation of the characters from human society, as well as from each
other.  Billy Budd has most of these elements as well.  Billy, the angelic
foretopman, winds up getting hung for administering justice -- striking
down the lying, sadistic master-at-arms, John Claggart.  Claggart himself
cares for nobody -- not the men under him, not the officers above him,
not even his henchman and snitch, Squeak.  He probably hates himself as
well.  The sailors, many of them seized by press-gangs, are far from
home, subject to a life of servitude and flogging.  They share the bonds
of prisoners, rather than of friends.  Indeed, Billy's ability to make
friends wins over the most cynical of them, the crewman Dansker.  Even
Captain Vere, the head of the ship, has few, if any connections.  He's
an intellectual ("Starry" Vere, the men call him), highly ambivalent
about what he's doing and what he's compelled to do (execute Budd, for
one).  The codes of war and the draconian discipline adhered to by even
such an "enlightened" man are as murderous as Billy and not nearly as
innocent.

So ran the criticisms forty years ago.  Now that interest in sexual
orientation and especially in "queer studies" has risen, we see (or at
least talk about) more than we used to.  Most people today realize that
Forster and Britten's artistic compulsion to explore difference reflects
their perception of their precarious status as homosexuals in straight
society.  However, both heretofore had found metaphors in the general
"outsider" Peter Grimes, Albert Herring, Stephen Wonham, and Dr.  Aziz,
for example.  Though still coded, Billy Budd represents the most open
expression of homosexual alienation for both artists up to that time.
Billy is called Beauty and Baby, and at least one sailor has a thing for
him.  In fact, Britten made compositional difficulties for himself.
Crozier, for example, kept pointing out that the entire cast was male,
and thus without the variety of treble voices.  For the most part, Britten
and Forster ignored him.  They finally included a cabin boy and a treble
chorus of powder-monkeys, perhaps just to stop his whining.  There's no
love duet, no conventional signpost for an operatic audience.

They also made several changes to Melville himself, some of them
significant.  The opera's Claggart, for example, is less enigmatic than
the original.  After all, his position as the major antagonist in a stage
drama somewhat obliges him to explain himself, and he does so very much
in terms of the self-loathing, closeted homosexual.  On the other hand,
Melville's Claggart never explains himself.  Like Moby Dick, his evil
remains mysterious and unmotivated, like a flood or an earthquake, where
the just suffer along with the unjust.  In Melville's story, Vere dies
shortly after Billy in a naval battle.  In the opera, he lives a long,
unhappy life -- long enough to suffer and to redeem himself through
suffering and understanding.  Oddly enough, Forster and Britten come
across as more old-fashioned than the nineteenth-century Melville.

The music has the brooding, stormy quality of Peter Grimes, perhaps
because both operas share the inspiration of the sea, but Billy Budd
seems more tightly-constructed than the earlier work.  Easily-identifiable
orchestral fragments comment on the action.  For example, the musical
refrain "O heave!  O heave away, heave!" on a sailor's chantey quickly
becomes a musical symbol for the oppressiveness of the crew's life.  It
comes back most tellingly at the very end, when the crew, on the brink
of mutiny over the death of Budd, disperse -- as the libretto states --
from "force of habit." Like Grimes as well, the opera has a few lighter
moments, like shafts of sunlight through black clouds, such as the
nonsense-rhymes of the sailors after the day's work, which I compare to
Grimes's "Old Joe has gone fishing." Furthermore, I find Budd more
dramatically pointed than Grimes.  Britten had learned something since,
adding to his natural dramatic skills.  The characterizations seem
sharper, less cartoonish, and more economical.  Vere's music is appropriately
quiet and reflective, Billy's soaring and a bit nayve.  Claggart's
characteristically lies low, tending in the vocal line to emphasize the
same pitch and thus underlining his purposeful obsession with destroying
Budd.

The opera contains little in the way of conventional aria (Billy's
soliloquy in chains is close to being an exception) but many brilliant
set-pieces, including Vere's listening to the crew's singing at night
and the battle-scene that opens the second act.  Throughout the opera,
Britten has mastered the clear exposition of several simultaneous planes
of action.  However, one also finds telling simplicity, especially in
some unearthly orchestral common chords as Vere goes off to tell Billy
the fatal judgment of the drum-head court.

This performance surpasses that of the composer himself on Decca. 
Britten was a fine conductor, but his Billy is curiously flat.  The
singers here are much better actors than in the Decca recording.  I'd
except Peter Pears.  The fact that he had passed his vocal prime I think
only added to the pathos of his portrayal of the sensitive Vere.  In
general, the cast indulges in very little "opera-singing." Instead, we
get singing speech.  Bostridge's Vere, though it misses Pears note of
maturity, has all the searching and flexibility of a Lieder singer.  You
can practically touch the malevolence of Gidon Saks's Claggart.  The
surprise for me was Matthew Best.  I know him as a conductor, but he's
an outstanding singer.  He plays Dansker, Billy's best friend, with
tragic depth.

Conductor Daniel Harding emerges as the hero of it all.  He has a firm
grasp on the overall shape of the drama, and again and again he builds
scenes and keeps things moving.  The sound is superb.

Steve Schwartz

             ***********************************************
The CLASSICAL mailing list is powered by L-Soft's renowned LISTSERV(R)
list management software together with L-Soft's HDMail High Deliverability
Mailer for reliable, lightning fast mail delivery.  For more information,
go to:  http://www.lsoft.com/LISTSERV-powered.html

ATOM RSS1 RSS2