I agree with Don Satz on everything except the requirement for conciseness.
While at the outset this may sound like a desired requisite it could result
in a less thorough review.  Some of our listers are very good writers and
have a lot to say about music.  I for one would not like to miss out on
their opinions and knowledge because of a conciseness requirement.  I can
think of one reviewer on this list in particular who has a lot to say about
music and I always await his reviews with great anticipation and pleasure
- no matter how long they are.  You can of course, as Mr.  Satz says, tune
out if you wish.

Thanks
Ed