David Harbin <[log in to unmask]> said:

>Can I throw my hat into the ring and name my favourite Bruckner recordings?
>Perhaps others out there can suggest their own favourite list:
>
>1.  Unsure.  Possibly the new Tintner when it is released.

It is now out and is absolutely at the top of the list.

>2.  Karajan/BPO

Chailly/RCO and Eichhorn/BO Linz (for the newer Carragan version -
Tintner as well).

>3.  Tinter/RSNO = FRSO/Inbal

Haitink/VPO (for 1877 version) and Bohm/VPO

>4.  Celibidache/Munich PO

Solonen/LA Phil (I was really surprised I liked this one) and Bohm/VPO

>5.  Welser Most/LPO = Furtwangler/BPO (1942)

agreement with W-M and Jochum/BavRSO (part of DG set)

>6.  Tinter/NZSO (despite the playing) Furtwangler/BPO (1942 again)

agree on the Tinter and Blomstedt/SFS

>7.  Knappertsbusch/VPO (1949).  No contest

Karajan/VPO and Eichhorn/BO Linz

>8.  Wand/NDRSO (1987 live Lubeck Cathedral) Horentsein/LSO

Guilini/VPO and Sinopoli/Dresden

>9.  Giulini/VPO (1989)

absolutely - and Skrowaczewski/Minnesota

Enjoy!

Michael Cucka <[log in to unmask]>