Philip Peters <[log in to unmask]>

>Pablo Massa wrote:
>
>>...  A few months ago, I got a score of Schubert's "Gute Nacht" (I from
>>"Winterreise") in a tenor voice version, in d minor.  As I have a dark
>>baritone voice (and poor vocal resources...), I found more natural and
>>comfortable to it in c minor.  However, it wasn't only a matter of
>>comfort:I thought that this key was more fitted to the song, given its
>>general character and text (which is, of course, a merely subjective
>>opinion).
>
>Winterreise was originally written for tenor voice.

So what?.  Tell Fischer-Dieskau...

By the way: should I write "The Original Tenor Version in D Minor", in
order to avoid obvious remarks as this?.  Does this remark has anything
to do with my comment (remember: "comfortable", "I thought", "subjective
opinion", etc)?.

Pablo Massa
[log in to unmask]