Philip Peters wrote:

>For HIP: Pinnock and Goebel for me, please...

Those are my exact preferences also, and they are both on the same label.
There have been quite a few more recent HIP recordings, but none attains
the superb pacing of the Pinnock or the outstanding brass playing and
excitement of the Goebel.  Personally, I think that in the newer
recordings, the artists are trying to offer "uniqueness" at the expense
of natural musicianship.  However, there's always the new set on Harmonia
Mundi.

Don Satz
[log in to unmask]