Philip Peters wrote:

>I wouldn't say they are *innocent*.  I don't think Beethoven ever
>composed *innocent* music.  Of course we would have to define
>*innocence* first which seems too difficult for a small mind like
>mine.

Mine too, but the dictionary folks have no problem.  My dictionary
uses terms including "freedom from sin or moral wrong, untainted, pure."
Different terms used included "simplicity, lack of knowledge or sense,
idiot-like." I prefer the former set of definitions, and with that in mind,
I'd say that the string trios, serenade, op.18 string quartets, op.2 piano
sonatas, and, to a degree, the first two symphonies and piano concerti are
relatively innocent(relatively is a great word - you can't get pinned
down).

Don Satz
[log in to unmask]