Subject: | |
From: | |
Date: | Wed, 23 Feb 2000 20:05:44 -0000 |
Content-Type: | text/plain |
Parts/Attachments: |
|
|
Ulvi Yurtsever wrote:
>What's the scoop on BWV 1036? In the only recording I have this is the
>same as the trio sonata from the Musical Offering (BWV 1079) transcribed
>to D minor (from C minor in the MO; although I am not even sure if it is
>transcribed to D minor, it is just advertised to be in D minor).
Hm, you really need a C P E Bach specialist to answer this since BWV
1036 is thought to be by him rather than by his father. It's listed as Wq
145, H 569 in the CPEB catalogues, and is pretty much ignored in the JSB
catalogues. The "New Grove" says of it: "...similar to trio sonata listed
as doubtful work of J.S. Bach (BWV 1036) [possibly] composed jointly by J.
S. and C.P.E Bach".
I would have thought that some mention would have been made if it was a
Musical Offering adaptation, so it sounds as though your CD is confused.
What CD is it? I have never come across a recording of this work. (or
alleged to be this work!)
all the best,
Simon Crouch.
|
|
|